Sorry, didn't get notified on the replies here (I don't get notifications from here at all anymore, not sure why). The passenger side headlight bucket needs some material trimmed off, and we had to pull down the bottom to fit it around the radiator support, but it does fit. It's stronger than it looks like it should be, didn't have any issues pulling it down.
Right now, I'm not 100% sure I'm going to use it, as the foglight bezels that are built into it are bugging me by not being round (they say just cut the hole round, it's a rounded edge, it'll look bad if you cut/sand it round). I'm going to look at cutting out the fog bezels, and fitting OEM ones in it. If they fit I'll probably use it, otherwise I'll use the Cervinis Cobra-R I picked up last week (brand new, never painted or mounted, $100 bucks)...
If I ever get my car running again, I'll start working on the bumper again..
I took it to my body man last week to check it out, and other than my concern with the bezels, his only concern was the thickness of it, but once he started looking at it, said it was sturdier than he thought it'd be for the thickness, and that it looked better than he thought it would.
If I get a chance tomorrow, I may fit it back on as it is, and get some pictures.