FWIW - here's my experience.
I just tried to do this about two weeks ago, and ended up reinstalling all the old stuff back on again.
I bought the little plug online and it didn't work. I got a CEL and my code reader said "EGR not opening properly" or something. Not only that, but my idle quality sucked, and the car didn't run right. Plus, your EGR actually helps your fuel mileage which was even more reason to put it back on.
I cleaned up the valve (knocked off the rust on the iron part) and polished the EGR tube. (which is stainless steel BTW) It doesn't look so bad now, and I don't have a stupid CEL. Someday when the car needs a chip I'll switch it off and remove all that stuff, but for now I'll just leave it.
Paul.
Well thats just made up my mind for me, its staying for the time being.