O man, I did this to my car one time. After giving it the belt dressing treatment to fix a minor sound, the car squealed like crazy! I changed out the idler pulley, the belt, and scrubed every ribbed pulley with a toothbrush to get all that junk off & that took care of it. Belt dressing may work great for some, but i'm staying away from it from now on. Hope you get it figured out!