Water-Methanol Injection

jfor441

Legend
Joined
Apr 5, 2006
Messages
8,482
Reaction score
2
The tuner I was looking to use, sent me this email after I had asked about his experience tuning with water-methanol:

I've tuned many different cars with water injection. As for using it for
daily driving use I heavily suggest against it. You will run out, I don't
care if have a 5 gallon water tank.

Now, I know the water-meth combo will run out eventually and then you have to fill the tank. Not a big deal but to me the tuner seems like he is saying it runs out every 1/4 tank.

So... I emailed Snow Performance about what the tuner said and this is one of their responses:

90% of our systems are installed on daily drivers, and our parking lot is filled with vehicles that run the systems every single day. We have different levels of cars and power, etc. but there is absolutely, positively, no reason you should have to fill the reservoir every day unless you travel 300-500 miles a day (even then not likely).



On an NA engine, there isn’t as much heat and pressure so we don’t inject as much volume of fluid – so a given quantity will last much longer. Take, for example, our ’05 Mustang turbo. Makes about 450+whp through an automatic. The 7qt reservoir lasts between one and two tanks of gasoline, and unless you light up the tires at every single stoplight, you should have that same or better range from a 7qt. We have optional low-fluid lights, and our Safe Injection Safeguard system is about 3 weeks away from being re-released which would allow complete safety against running out or any other fluid delivery issue.



It almost sounds like your tuner has been installing the nozzles backwards which causes the fluid to come out in a stream, not a mist, and uses about 10 times as much fluid (therefore 10 times as fast).


So... after I read the above email, here is my response to them:

That is awesome to hear! My goal with my car is to try to make 360+ HP naturally aspirated. I have been told by another engine builder that on race gas they are able to make 380 to the wheels on combo similar to what I am going to run, except they don't use water-meth injection. I was looking into the water-meth injection simply for the ability of being able run pump gas. I know that I will still have the added benefit of increasing the timing. Which of your kits would be the best choice for my combo? Also, what else would you recommend I purchase along with the stage 2 MAF boost cooler? I know the 7qt reservoir.


Their reply:

Normally, we equal or better 116 octane power numbers, so you should be able to do the same. For your setup, I would recommend the #20011 Stage 2 MAF Boost Cooler that injects proportionally according to the airflow going into the engine. If you run the 7 qt in the trunk, I would recommend the #40060 Solenoid to prevent gravity flow if you ever parked nose down on a steep hill. Just to be safe.





That being said, do ya'll think I should try this guy out or go somewhere else? If I have to drive 3 or 4 hours with car on a trailer I will do it. I just HAVE to have the BEST tune possible for what I am wanting to do with my car.
 

Bluesn95

Active Member
Joined
Jul 22, 2007
Messages
260
Reaction score
0
Location
Waco
I've been wanting badly to try snow performance. I don't know anyone that uses it but everything I've read about it was good and I believe that you don't run out very often. I don't think that tuner knew what he was talking about. I'm building a high compression 2 valve and want to use methenal injection. How much does a system run anyways ? I think you should go for it.
 

19mustang95

Legend
Joined
Jun 25, 2006
Messages
6,132
Reaction score
5
i would go to another tuner if he doesn't trust the abilities of meth..

i know in boosted applications that the meth is only used when under boost, so it can last a long time. but i don't now much abotu it being used NA.
 
OP
OP
J

jfor441

Legend
Joined
Apr 5, 2006
Messages
8,482
Reaction score
2
Bluesn95 said:
I've been wanting badly to try snow performance. I don't know anyone that uses it but everything I've read about it was good and I believe that you don't run out very often. I don't think that tuner knew what he was talking about. I'm building a high compression 2 valve and want to use methenal injection. How much does a system run anyways ? I think you should go for it.

The system total for everything I am looking at is around 600 total. That may seem expensive, but look at the costs of running race gas on a daily basis.


From what Snow performance AND other manufacturers of meth kits say, the meth should definitely last for at least 1 tank of gas.

Bluesn95... The meth kit is a definite, if it doesn't work like I am hoping, then I will have to redo my entire plans LOL.
 

quickstang_1994

Well-Known Member
Joined
Apr 30, 2006
Messages
2,190
Reaction score
12
Location
Cross Anchor, SC
Even there web site says it wont last 12 1/4mile passes. If you play on the street it will not last. The question I'm asking myself "Is the added power worth losing the car?" If you run out even by accident the motor is going to give.
 
OP
OP
J

jfor441

Legend
Joined
Apr 5, 2006
Messages
8,482
Reaction score
2
quickstang_1994 said:
Even there web site says it wont last 12 1/4mile passes. If you play on the street it will not last. The question I'm asking myself "Is the added power worth losing the car?" If you run out even by accident the motor is going to give.

Thats with the little tank that comes with the kit. I am going to upgrade to the 7qt tank. That's a little over 1.5 gal. That should be more than enough.
 

Jrgunn5150

Post Whore
Joined
Jun 29, 2007
Messages
12,273
Reaction score
2
Is the added cost of the methanol you'll need to add every few days still less than race gas? And is this car your sole transportation? If it is you may want to consider picking up a beater.
 

Dalamar

Post Whore
Joined
Feb 3, 2006
Messages
13,823
Reaction score
133
Location
SLC, UT
I'm adding water Meth to my car.
and it's WAAAY cheaper than race gas.

It sounds like the tuner is worried about running out while on a Meth tune. It will be set to advance the timing with the added octain from the meth, you run out, and you'll get detonation. detonation is not your motor's friend.

I'm pretty sure they have low level notification avaliable for the snow kit.
 
OP
OP
J

jfor441

Legend
Joined
Apr 5, 2006
Messages
8,482
Reaction score
2
Jrgunn5150 said:
Is the added cost of the methanol you'll need to add every few days still less than race gas? And is this car your sole transportation? If it is you may want to consider picking up a beater.

116 octane race gas about 9 bucks a gallon here. The -30 below windshield wiper fluid from wally world is 30% methanol and distilled water plus two bottles of the yellow HEET makes a 50/50 mixture of meth and water. That will cost me maybe 4 bucks per fill up.

Filling up with race gas would 135 per tank. Filling up with 87 octane plus the water-meth is 42.55. Both of those are assuming a bone dry tank at 15 gallons.

I can also get a 55gal drum of pure methanol for 190 bucks. Then I can get a gallon of distilled water from wally world for less than 1.50 a gallon. That would be around 5 bucks a gallon. Still alot cheaper than race gas.



And yes Dalamar, I will be getting all the safety stuff. Low level indicator and also the safe injection stuff from Snow. I'll also have a couple antifreeze bottles premixed and carried in the car in case I run low have to refill.
 

Jrgunn5150

Post Whore
Joined
Jun 29, 2007
Messages
12,273
Reaction score
2
Sweet, I've never even looked into it. I just keep my boost low and be happy. But that is pretty interesting, especially since I have a beater to drive to and from work.
 
OP
OP
J

jfor441

Legend
Joined
Apr 5, 2006
Messages
8,482
Reaction score
2
Jrgunn5150 said:
Sweet, I've never even looked into it. I just keep my boost low and be happy. But that is pretty interesting, especially since I have a beater to drive to and from work.

It is definitely something to look into. Lots of good information out there.
 

quickstang_1994

Well-Known Member
Joined
Apr 30, 2006
Messages
2,190
Reaction score
12
Location
Cross Anchor, SC
race gas on the street? How much power are you trying to push? And even with the larger tank you want have enough for a play day or night without stopping to fill up.
 
OP
OP
J

jfor441

Legend
Joined
Apr 5, 2006
Messages
8,482
Reaction score
2
quickstang_1994 said:
race gas on the street? How much power are you trying to push? And even with the larger tank you want have enough for a play day or night without stopping to fill up.

It's not how much power, it's how much compression. I have said before, I am building a high compression NA motor. Also gone run nitrous on it at the track.
 
OP
OP
J

jfor441

Legend
Joined
Apr 5, 2006
Messages
8,482
Reaction score
2
quickstang_1994 said:
With high compression(depending on how high) you will need race gas all the time. A meth kit can not be used all the time like it will be needed.

That is where you are wrong. Water-methanol injection does 2 things. It cools the intake charge and slows the burn of the fuel. By cooling the intake/cylinder and slowing the burn, 91 octane gasoline has an effective rating of 116 octane race fuel. This allows you to run higher compression or more boost on pump fuel and increase power by 2 ways. First way is noticed on a forced induction motor. It cools the intake charge significantly. The 2nd way is that it allows to run a LOT more timing than you normally would be able to.

What do you think the point of water-methanol injection is? I have been researching this for a while now. I have gotten all my information from many different sources.
 

ripper

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2007
Messages
3,233
Reaction score
4
SNOWS low level indicator is a tiny little red bulb LOL. I had a kit on my car and still have the light. If you could trust yourself seeing this come on during the day ok. Otherwise you will need something else.

Here it is



[attachment deleted by admin]
 

quickstang_1994

Well-Known Member
Joined
Apr 30, 2006
Messages
2,190
Reaction score
12
Location
Cross Anchor, SC
jfor441 said:
quickstang_1994 said:
With high compression(depending on how high) you will need race gas all the time. A meth kit can not be used all the time like it will be needed.

That is where you are wrong. Water-methanol injection does 2 things. It cools the intake charge and slows the burn of the fuel. By cooling the intake/cylinder and slowing the burn, 91 octane gasoline has an effective rating of 116 octane race fuel. This allows you to run higher compression or more boost on pump fuel and increase power by 2 ways. First way is noticed on a forced induction motor. It cools the intake charge significantly. The 2nd way is that it allows to run a LOT more timing than you normally would be able to.

What do you think the point of water-methanol injection is? I have been researching this for a while now. I have gotten all my information from many different sources.
It is not made to run 24/7 is what I am saying so you will be running 91 until you give it gas.
 

DropTopPony

Post Whore
Joined
Jan 12, 2006
Messages
15,182
Reaction score
223
Location
South Jersey
I've done alot of research on the Snow Meth kits and have PM'd many guys using it on KB'd Cobra's/Lightnings etc (I was curious how it worked with eaton/twin screw blowers) and all have said the consumption is not that much and with the standard sized tank that comes with the kit they will top it off when they fill up on gas...none that i asked have ever run out and even if it did run out the Snow kit has safety measures to retard your timing so you don't amage your engine...I will be using it on my car.
 

quickstang_1994

Well-Known Member
Joined
Apr 30, 2006
Messages
2,190
Reaction score
12
Location
Cross Anchor, SC
those all have intercoolers. I did talk to a guy about the safety kit so I will look into to it a little more. the consumption is 12 quartermile passes on the reservoir that comes with the kit
 

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
78,527
Messages
1,535,651
Members
16,185
Latest member
dmen76

Members online

Top