I would definitely check the plugs, even though their a pain to get to. But it could also be the coils. Because if it smells rich somethings obviously preventing the fuel to burn. It might be the plugs or maybe its just pouring too much in for the plugs to handle( which would foul them out). So i would check those and then post a reply with a picture of the plug if possible and i would be able to tell you my accurate opinion if i saw one.
The car says 52k, but we all know what certain people do. I really don't know how old O2's are.
Im thinkin o2 also. I just got done scanning it again. He said it looks good, Fuel Trim was good. He is scanning it for free and after work so who really knows. I just wish i could fig this out. :BangHead:
Had a smoke test done today and NOTHING. No Vac leaks.